E-Evidence: Notification of the Enforcing Authority

The e-Evidence Regulation allows law enforcement authorities to address European Production Orders directly to service providers in another Member State. Where particularly sensitive data are concerned, however, the relationship between the issuing authority and the service provider does not always remain this direct.

“We only see what we know”

As a control mechanism, the notification requirement serves to protect fundamental rights and national particularities where the interference with privacy is particularly serious. As a rule, notification is required where a European Production Order concerns content data or traffic data. For the less sensitive subscriber data and data requested for the sole purpose of identifying the user, by contrast, no such notification generally takes place.

There is, however, one exception to the notification requirement. It does not apply where the issuing authority has reasonable grounds to believe that the offence has been committed, is being committed or is likely to be committed in the issuing State and that the person whose data are sought resides there.

Where notification is required, the issuing authority not only transmits the EPOC to the addressee but at the same time also notifies the competent enforcing authority. In addition to the service provider and the issuing authority, the enforcing authority thus becomes involved in the procedure. This constellation has a direct impact on when the provider may produce the data.

Outside emergency cases, the requested data may not simply be produced straight away. The notification has suspensive effect and gives the enforcing authority the opportunity to review the order. If it confirms before the end of the 10-day period that it will not raise any grounds for refusal, the provider must transmit the data as soon as possible, and at the latest after ten days. If it does not respond within this period, the data are produced once the ten days have elapsed. If, on the other hand, it raises grounds for refusal, the data are either not produced at all or production is limited to the data still covered by an adapted order.

For the service provider, this results in a twofold task. It must preserve the data immediately and prepare them for production, but may only transmit them once the 10-day period has expired or the enforcing authority has expressly confirmed that it has no objections. Premature transmission is just as risky as a delayed response.

With EviGate, service providers can master this challenge as well. EviGate reviews incoming orders in a structured manner and captures the data category – the criterion that determines whether a notification case exists. Automated deadline monitoring keeps track of the 10-day period, which in these cases determines the time of production. In addition, EviGate provides a legally sound connection to the European judicial communication system e-CODEX. This makes it possible to keep a complete overview of orders and communications from authorities, even in notification cases – without any in-house code or infrastructure.

Stay up to date: Subscribe to updates – by email or RSS